Silicone vs Hard Phone Cases: Which is More Protective?

Plastic phone cases, especially hard plastic cases, are generally seen as more protective than silicone options. But silicone cases can still offer exceptional protection, and combination cases with both silicone and plastic are also great options. 

This post will examine whether silicone or hard phone cases offer more protection. I’ll break down what each type of case offers and give you some other relevant information to keep in mind if you want a new case. 

Let’s get started. 

Key Takeaways

  • Hard plastic phone cases are generally the most protective case you can get. This type of phone case is durable and can withstand severe impacts. 
  • Silicone phone cases also offer solid protection and work well for most people. You just don’t get as much protection as plastic. 
  • A combination of silicone and plastic is a good option for anyone who wants good protection without the added bulk of all plastic. 

Silicon Phone Case vs Hard Case

No matter your phone type, it’s always good to protect your investment. A good case is vital in making that happen, and you should purchase a case as soon as you have the phone out of its box. 

But what’s the difference between a silicone and a hard phone case? Let’s take a quick look at that now. 

A hard plastic case is the best option if you want the most protection possible. These cases offer a level of protection that softer phone cases can’t match and will keep your device protected from many different sources of potential damage. 

Hard plastic cases can be bulky, which is one of the downsides of using them. And while this might result in the phone not fitting in your pocket as well, you won’t need to worry about dropping it on the ground. 

Silicone cases also offer pretty excellent protection. In most situations, a silicone phone case is a good option for keeping a phone in good shape and reducing the risk of damage in everyday situations. 

Many people like silicone cases because they offer a more streamlined fit over the phone. This fit keeps the phone’s original profile in shape, so it’s less bulky and easier to put in a pocket. But a silicone case won’t offer quite as much protection from impacts.

I’m a big fan of using a combination case that uses both hard plastic and silicone. This is the best of both worlds, in my opinion. You get the streamlined fit that silicone offers with the added protection that comes from using hard plastic. 

Disadvantages of Silicone Case

I don’t think there are too many disadvantages to using a silicone phone case other than a bit of a reduction in protection compared to a hard plastic case. Silicone cases are convenient and affordable, making them an excellent option to explore. 

Silicone cases have some downsides, which are worth knowing about before buying one. I already mentioned less protection than hard plastic cases, but silicone cases will also wear out more quickly than plastic cases. 

Thin silicone can start to break and tear after heavy use, which any phone case is likely to encounter. This can make it a worse value compared to a case that is built to last longer. 

Silicone cases can also store more heat than plastic options. A hot phone might run into issues with performance. If you live in a hot region or use your phone when it is hot out, this is something to consider with silicone.  

Remember that hard plastic cases also have disadvantages, such as bulking and making it more difficult to access your phone when needed. It’s important to weigh these disadvantages when making the best choice for your situation.

Choosing a Protective Phone Case: What to Consider


To ensure your case offers the maximum amount of protection, always get a model made with hard, durable materials.

Weak plastic will just break on the first or second drop, while synthetic options tend to hold up over time.

Build Quality

When picking out a phone case, build quality is also incredibly important. Many companies combine materials like rubber and plastic in a way that provides excellent protection at all times.

Getting a cheap case with a bad design won’t just lead to problems, it will put your phone in jeopardy.


If you enjoy consuming media from your phone (YouTube, Netflix, etc), you should get a case with a kickstand.

That will allow you to sit the phone down and watch videos without having to hold it upright. Extremely convenient if this is your preferred way to watch your favorite shows.


Here are a few quick answers to some of the most commonly asked questions relating to if silicone or hard phone cases offer more protection. 

What type of phone cases are most protective? 

Hard plastic cases are generally seen as the most protective. But these can be bulky and inconvenient. More and more people are using a combination of silicone and hard plastic for excellent protection from impact and shock. 

Are hard or soft cases most protective? 

Hard cases can be more protective when it comes to impacts, while soft cases can better absorb impacts. That makes a combination case that uses both hard and soft materials an ideal case with protection in mind.

Who makes the most protective phone case? 

Several companies are known for making very protective phone cases, and Otterbox is one of these. Otterbox cases are capable of protecting a phone from severe impacts and other damage.

Other Useful Tips

If you’re picking up a good-quality protective case for your phone, we suggest buying a high-quality screen protector. That will ensure your screen doesn’t get damaged or scratched when it’s hit.

Cases only offer minimal protection by adding a lip around the screen to keep it from laying on flat surfaces. These screen protectors just add an extra layer.

You also want a cleaning cloth for the screen. Even with a screen protector on your phone, it is going to get smudged from texting, calling, and everyday use.

Wiping it with a shirt or other cloth is not a great idea. Get a dedicated cloth to keep your screen scratch-free.

Final Thoughts 

Any phone case is better than none at all. But if you are looking for the most protective option available, a hard plastic case will do better in the long run compared to a softer silicone case. A combination of these two materials can also be ideal. 

A good phone case should last for a long time and do a solid job of offering continuous protection. But keep in mind that no case will protect your phone indefinitely and that you might have to get a new one from time to time. 

What type of phone case do you prefer – silicone or hard? Why? Let me know in the comments below. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *